L to R: Wet n Wild Rest in Pieces, Once Upon a Time and Glow in the Dark. I'm missing Nail in the Coffin which is a black with silver and orange microglitter. I do not have a swatch of the Glow in the Dark one. My camera will not pick it up but trust me it's very glowy! It looks great over white!
Wet n Wild Fantasy Makers Rest in Pieces. This is a black jelly with purple microglitter. It goes on a little thin but builds well to full opacity. This 3-coats total with top coat.
For fun I mattified it with Essie's Matte About You.
Here's a rare hard to find Fantasy Makers polish I own:
If you can't fine tombstone polishes in your area, here's some dupes:
Wet n Wild Shine Night Prowl and Rest in Pieces are dupes. Night Prowl used to be on the regular Wild Shine display. It seems to have been taken off now. You might still be able to find it in the sale bins.
NYX Girls Dorothy is a dupe for Once Upon a Time. I've been able to find NYX Girls polishes at random beauty shops or online at Amazon or Cherry Culture (their shipping is outrageously high for polish). I had a thing where I had to buy the all cheaper dupes for Deborah Lippman polishes. I have to say that the formula for Dorothy is not so good and is really slow drying and will easily ding/smudge.
Final Thoughts & Availability?
Last year, these polishes were in drugstores on the regular Halloween display. This year it seems to be replaced with the Halloween Megalast polishes which is a set of foil shades. I was able to find these at the Halloween Superstore for $4 and if you can wait a day, they will be 50% off. I liked the tombstone bottles but disappointed that they are recycled colors from last year or from different collections. I was hoping for some new and unique glitter mixes. Oh well, there's always next year, right?
Did you buy any of the Wet n Wild Halloween polishes?
If so, what shades did you get?
Thanks for reading!